Ask for a dated work log that names each SEO task, affected page or issue, and evidence you can review. Compare it with the agreed scope, then assess Search Console trends and recorded enquiries separately. Search changes can take time and results are not guaranteed, so low enquiries alone do not prove that no work was done.

Search engine optimization (SEO) work can include research, technical recommendations, content changes and reporting. A ranking chart alone does not show which tasks the provider completed or whether those tasks matched your agreement.

This guide helps South African service businesses review an existing provider or prepare to hire one. Compare dated work evidence with your agreed scope, then review Search Console and enquiry measures as separate evidence. Google says changes can take from hours to several months to affect Search results, and it does not guarantee indexing or rankings. Set review points with the provider around your scope and baseline, rather than treating one timeline as a universal test. See Google’s SEO Starter Guide and advice on hiring an SEO.

Updated 6 November 2026: added current Google sources, clarified what Search Console can show, and separated work records from search and enquiry outcomes.

What records should you ask for?

Ask for evidence that matches the work in your agreement. Google recommends asking an SEO to explain proposed changes and provide details about the recommendations and their reasoning. The specific records you need will depend on the scope.

Work and change records

  • A dated activity log that separates completed work from work planned, blocked or waiting for approval.
  • The affected page, technical issue or campaign for each task, with a plain-language reason.
  • A link or other evidence for the change, such as a page URL, issue record or before-and-after notes. Ask what changed on the live site and when.
  • A content log showing which pages were created, updated or removed and why.

Search and business measures

  • A Google Search Console report with the date range and filters shown, grouped by query or page where useful. Its Performance report includes clicks, impressions, click-through rate and average position. Average position is an aggregate for the selected report, not a fixed rank every person sees. See the Performance report guide.
  • A record of the enquiries, calls or bookings your business received, plus the tracking method used to label an enquiry as organic search. If your form, analytics or sales log cannot connect a source to an enquiry, label it unknown instead of guessing.
  • A short explanation that separates work completed from results observed.

Keep access to your own Search Console property. Google recommends giving read-only access when an SEO is carrying out an initial audit. For ongoing work, agree on the access needed for the tasks and retain a record of changes made.

What questions should you ask the agency?

Use these questions to compare proposals and review an active engagement. Google’s hiring guidance also recommends asking about prior work, expected results and timeframe, local or industry experience, communication, and how the provider will explain changes.

Before work starts

  • What is included in the agreed scope, and what needs separate approval or payment?
  • Which pages, technical issues or search opportunities are in scope, and why?
  • What baseline will we use, which business goal matters, and how will we review progress?
  • What access, approvals or business information do you need from us?
  • What will you report, how often, and what can the report not prove?
  • Do you guarantee a ranking, claim a special relationship with Google, or promise priority submission? Google says no provider can guarantee a first-place ranking. Its third-party SEO guidance also says Google does not evaluate or endorse third-party SEO tools.

At each review

  • Which tasks were completed, which were deferred, and what evidence shows the difference?
  • What changed on the site, who approved it and when did it go live?
  • Which Search Console pages or queries changed over a comparable date range? What other changes or market events could explain the movement?
  • How does the business track organic visits and enquiries? Which records can be linked, and which sources remain unknown?
  • What should happen next, who owns each action, and what will you check at the next agreed review?

If an answer uses terms such as “ongoing optimisation,” ask for the dated task, affected page or issue, and supporting evidence. The provider should explain those details in plain language.

How should you read a ranking report?

A ranking report can help you follow a selected search query over time, but it answers a narrow question. It does not show by itself whether a page received clicks, whether visitors made contact or whether the query matches your customers.

For Google Search, note the tracker’s query, location, device and date settings. Search Console’s Performance report groups clicks and impressions by query or page, while its average position is aggregated across impressions. A selected-query tracker position and Search Console average position are different measures; do not expect the numbers to match. Compare like-for-like periods and settings where possible, and ask the provider to explain the measurement method. Search results can also vary by time, location, device and search history. Do not compare screenshots captured with different settings as if they were the same measurement.

Search Console does not identify the exact query behind each individual enquiry. It aggregates query data and omits some queries for privacy. Compare query and page trends with organic-traffic and enquiry records only where your tracking connects them. Otherwise, report the gap rather than claiming a query produced a customer.

How can you connect SEO activity to enquiries?

Keep three records separate, then compare them at the same review point:

  1. Work completed: the dated task log, pages changed and technical issues addressed.
  2. Search activity: Search Console impressions, clicks and average position for the agreed pages or queries, with the date range and filters recorded.
  3. Business enquiries: calls, forms, bookings or sales recorded by your business, with source marked only when the tracking supports it.

Look for changes that line up in time, but do not treat timing as proof that the agency caused the outcome. Google notes that other events can affect Search performance and that changes may not produce a noticeable result. Ask the provider to explain what the available data supports, what it cannot connect, and what they recommend checking next.

Which warning signs deserve follow-up?

Ask for clarification or evidence when:

  • the only report is a ranking screenshot with no record of the work in scope;
  • the same tasks or keywords appear each month without dates, reasons or a discussion of what changed;
  • the provider cannot show you your Search Console data or explain the filters and date range;
  • “ongoing optimisation” is not backed by specific tasks or recommendations;
  • the provider promises a number-one ranking, claims a special relationship with Google, or says a third-party tool is approved by Google; or
  • the provider will not explain what changes they made, why they made them or which methods they use.

One unanswered question is a reason to ask for detail, not proof that no work took place. Keep the agreement, reports, approvals and change records together so you can compare delivery with the written scope.

Check the agreement before you sign or leave

Contract terms differ. Before work starts, confirm the deliverables, reporting, approvals, fees, renewal and cancellation terms, access to accounts, and what happens to content or other assets if the work ends. Read the notice period and exit steps in your own agreement; this article does not determine what a particular clause means.

If you are considering ending an engagement, first ask for a written account of completed work, unresolved tasks, access and transfer steps, and any ongoing costs. A change in rankings after an agency leaves does not by itself show why the rankings changed. Check what services, pages, tracking or other assets changed, then seek independent advice if the evidence and agreement still do not line up.

A simple monthly review record

Use one row or section for each review period:

Record What to write down
Agreed work Task, page or issue, owner and due point
Work status Completed, deferred, blocked or awaiting approval, with dated evidence
Search data Search Console report, selected pages or queries, filters and comparable date ranges
Enquiries Recorded contacts, source when known, and source-tracking limits
Next actions What will change or be checked next, who owns it and when you will review it

Use this record as the agenda for the next review.

Where to start

Read the agreement, choose one review period and ask for the work log, Search Console view and enquiry-tracking method. If the evidence does not answer your questions, request a written explanation or a second opinion. Before proceeding, ask what records the review covers, whether it is paid, and whether the reviewer may also propose SEO services. For background on local SEO decisions, see our guide to local SEO for South African service businesses.

If you want help reviewing the records, describe the situation and include the questions you need answered.